Innovation at risk
The "Edelman 2024 Trust Barometer" report analyzes trust in a range of institutions, innovations, and social changes worldwide. It examines topics such as public perception of technological innovation, trust across industrial sectors, and how politics and the economy affect trust in companies and governments. In addition,…

The «Edelman 2024 Trust Barometer» report focuses on analyzing trust in various institutions, innovations and social changes at a global level.
The report examines topics such as public perception of technological innovation, trust across different industrial sectors, and how politics and the economy affect trust in businesses and governments.
It also explores the relationship between economic prosperity and levels of trust, as well as the role of public-private collaboration in promoting innovation and economic growth.
The report's title, *»Innovation in peril»* ((Innovación en peligro)), refers to the concern that poor management of innovation, combined with a lack of government regulation and distrust of traditional leaders, as well as suspicions about the independence of science, can put at risk the progress and acceptance of new technologies and innovations.
This concept suggests that there are significant challenges on the road to the effective development and implementation of innovations in society.
Here I share the top 10 identified by the Barometer, a quick tool for observing the global behavior of innovation and comparing it with our actions in the local context:
- Acceptance is as important as invention: Poor management of innovation is aggravated by a lack of government regulation, distrust of traditional leaders and suspicions about the independence of science.
- The virtuous circle of trust: Trust is based first on economic prosperity, where developing countries tend to have higher levels of trust than developed ones.
- Businesses must lead in innovation: Innovation is fundamental to business growth, and businesses are seen as more competent and ethical than governments.
- Society is changing too fast: Many believe that change is too fast and does not benefit ordinary people, with concerns about a bias toward the rich.
- AI is the battleground, but mRNA-based medicine is also at a crossroads: There is ambivalence toward innovations such as AI and genetic medicine.
- Concern about the loss of science's independence: Many feel that science has become politicized and that governments exert too much control.
- Employees are on par with scientists: Seventy-four percent say they trust scientists and employees equally to learn the truth about innovations. Among those who think innovation is poorly managed, employees are trusted more (72 percent) than scientists (68 percent).
- Innovation is politicized in Western democracies: There are significant differences in the acceptance of innovations among political groups in countries such as the U.S., Australia, Germany and Canada.
- Demand for public-private partnerships is growing: Trust has grown in companies that partner with the government on innovation.
- Trust in industrial sectors does not guarantee trust in innovation: There is a trust gap between sectors and their specific innovations, such as technology and AI, health and genetic medicine, and food and beverages and genetically modified foods.
Why is innovation at risk?
According to Edelman, innovation is at risk because of how this element works in governments' favor ahead of the elections coming up around the world this year. Technically, the report offers several key reasons:
- Poor management of innovation: There is growing concern about how innovations are being developed and managed. This includes concerns about the speed of change, the lack of consideration for ethical and social consequences, and the possibility that innovations disproportionately benefit specific groups (such as the wealthiest) at the expense of others.
- Lack of government regulation: Technological innovation often outpaces governments' capacity to regulate it adequately. This lack of regulation can lead to exploitation, misuse of technologies, and concerns about privacy and security.
- Distrust of traditional leaders and experts: There is growing distrust of those who have traditionally led and advised on innovation, including business leaders, politicians, and scientists. This may be due to perceptions of self-interest, lack of transparency, or conflicts of interest.
- Doubts about the neutrality of science: The perception that science may be influenced by politics or corporate interests undermines trust in scientific findings and in innovations based on them. This can lead to public resistance to adopting new technologies or science-based practices.
- Social and ethical impact of innovation: Ethical and social concerns, such as the impact of artificial intelligence on employment or privacy, can generate resistance and fear toward new technologies. The lack of dialogue and understanding on these issues between the public and innovators can aggravate these problems.
Innovation is at risk because of the combination of inadequate management and regulation, distrust of authorities and experts, and unresolved ethical and social concerns. The use of innovation as political capital is reflected in initiatives that include the same key actors, institutions, and recipients of the resources.
This creates an environment in which the adoption and effective use of innovations are hindered, which can hold back the progress and social benefit these innovations could bring.
The Edelman 2024 Trust Barometer fully matches the concerns set out in the Global Innovation Index 2023, where the Dominican Republic has dropped four places from the previous year in the Global Innovation Index, ranking 94 out of 132 economies.
Innovation is at risk because the same development formula keeps being repeated, and it is neither neutral nor balanced.