Institutional Challenges in Innovation Management

The Edelman Trust Barometer Global Report 2024 includes data on Latin American countries such as Argentina, Brazil, Colombia and Mexico, measuring trust in institutions such as NGOs, businesses, governments and the media. The report shows variations in trust levels across these countries and compares them with global trends. It provides…

The Edelman Trust Barometer Global Report 2024 includes data on Latin American countries such as Argentina, Brazil, Colombia and Mexico, measuring trust in institutions such as NGOs, businesses, governments and the media.

The report shows variations in trust levels across these countries and compares them with global trends. It offers insight into how these countries view issues such as technological innovations, economic fears, social change and government competence.

The 2024 Edelman Trust Barometer data show that trust in institutions, businesses and leaders varies across the Latin American countries included in the report. Some figures and comparisons follow:

  • Argentina: Trust in government has fallen significantly over the past 10 years, from 42% in 2014 to 16% in 2024. Trust in the media has also fallen, from 47% in 2014 to 23% in 2024. Trust in business has risen, from 47% in 2014 to 56%.
  • Brazil: Trust in government has fallen significantly over the past 10 years, from 51% in 2014 to 20% in 2024. Trust in business has also fallen, from 61% in 2014 to 44% in 2024. Trust in the media has risen, from 34% in 2014 to 41% in 2024.
  • Colombia: Trust in government has fallen significantly over the past 10 years, from 47% in 2014 to 20% in 2024. Trust in business has also fallen, from 61% in 2014 to 44% in 2024. Trust in the media has risen slightly, from 38% in 2014 to 40% in 2024.
  • Mexico: Trust in government has fallen significantly over the past 10 years, from 44% in 2014 to 16% in 2024. Trust in business has also fallen, from 57% in 2014 to 35% in 2024. Trust in the media has risen slightly, from 36% in 2014 to 38% in 2024.

Overall, trust in government has dropped significantly in all the Latin American countries included in the report. Trust in business has also fallen in most of them, while trust in the media has risen slightly or held steady.

The data help explain public sentiment in Latin America regarding institutional trust and social concerns.

The theme of the Edelman Trust Barometer 2024 addresses the phrase «Innovation In Peril» (Innovación en Peligro), referring to several key aspects of how innovation is managed and perceived in these countries:

  • The Importance of Implementation: It notes that poorly managed innovations can provoke rejection as well as progress in society. Examples of major innovations are artificial intelligence, vaccines and green energy. It is essential to explain the science behind these innovations and to manage their impacts.
  • Business Partnership for Change: Businesses are the most trusted to introduce innovations into society, which underscores the importance of partnering with government. CEOs are expected to protect jobs and take a position on emerging ethical concerns.
  • Integrating Science with Society: Although scientists are still trusted, they face growing public scrutiny. To build trust in expert recommendations, it is crucial to explain the research, engage in dialogue and use peer voices as advocates.
  • Control over the Future: When people feel they have control over how innovations affect their lives, they are more likely to accept them.

These points highlight the importance of careful, transparent management of innovation, as well as the need for collaboration across sectors so that innovations are beneficial and well received by society.

Governments, less competent than business

According to the Edelman Trust Barometer Global Report 2024, governments are perceived as significantly less competent than businesses. This is reflected in the competence score assigned to each of these sectors. The report uses a net score based on surveys to calculate these values.

In this context, governments obtained a net competence score between -35 and -15, while businesses are not specifically mentioned in the cited segment. However, the report highlights that governments are 52 points less competent than businesses, which indicates a marked difference in the perception of competence between these two sectors.

This suggests that, in general, people trust the capacity and efficiency of companies more than those of governments to manage and carry out their responsibilities.

Can public-private partnerships help innovation?

PPPs (public-private partnerships) can play a crucial role in restoring trust in the management of innovation. According to the Edelman Trust Barometer Global Report 2024, there are several key aspects in this process:

  • The Importance of Implementation: Poorly managed innovations can cause as much rejection as benefit in society. With significant advances in areas such as artificial intelligence, vaccines and green energy at stake, it is essential to explain the science behind these innovations and manage their impacts effectively.
  • The Need for Partnerships between Businesses and Governments: Businesses are seen as the most trusted to introduce innovations into society, but with an emphasis on partnering with governments. CEOs are expected to protect jobs and address emerging ethical concerns.
  • Integrating Science with Society: Although scientists still enjoy trust, they are increasingly subject to public scrutiny. To build trust in experts' recommendations, it is crucial to explain the research, engage in dialogue and use peer voices as advocates.

These points highlight how public-private partnerships can contribute to better management of innovation, by ensuring that technological and scientific advances are well communicated, ethically managed and socially integrated.

These collaborations can help balance the efficiency and agility of the private sector with the accountability and reach of the public sector, thereby improving public trust in innovation.

«When institutions mismanage innovation, we feel that both technology and society are leaving us behind…»

The Edelman Trust Barometer Global Report 2024 presents the phrase «When Institutions mismanage Innovation, we feel both Technology and Society are leaving Us behind» referring to the public perception that institutions' mismanagement of innovation can lead to a feeling of disconnection and disadvantage.

This concern is linked to the perception that innovation is being poorly managed and does not benefit ordinary people. The report indicates a growing sense that the system is biased in favor of the wealthy. For example, 82% of respondents globally believe the system is biased in favor of the wealthy, an increase of 29 percentage points over the previous baseline of 53%.

These data suggest that when institutions (such as governments, businesses and other bodies) do not manage innovation adequately, a perception of injustice and inequality can emerge. This, in turn, can lead people to feel that both technology and society at large are leaving them behind, potentially exacerbating inequalities and eroding trust in these institutions.

Wildcard at the ballot box

Innovation is a central and critical issue that the public is considering and evaluating, much as political candidates and policies are evaluated during an election.

This implies that decisions, actions and investment related to innovation, such as technological advances, scientific developments and the narrative of social change, are of significant importance to bureaucrats and government leaders.

The idea of using innovation as political capital changes the direction and management of innovation. It has become a key focal point for public opinion, debate and decision-making, increasing the attention paid to political matters during elections.

Is innovation in danger?

According to Edelman, the combination of inadequate management and regulation, distrust of authorities and experts, and unresolved ethical and social concerns. The use of innovation as political capital is reflected in initiatives that include the same key actors, institutions and recipients of the resources.

This creates an environment where the adoption and effective use of innovations are hindered, which can hold back the progress and the social benefit these innovations could deliver.

The Edelman 2024 Trust Barometer fully matches the concerns set out in the Global Innovation Index 2023, where the Dominican Republic has dropped four places compared with the previous year in the Global Innovation Index, ranking 94 out of 132 economies.

Innovation is at risk because the same development formula keeps being repeated, and it is neither neutral nor balanced.

Innovationis for everyone.