The Dilemma of Overvaluing IT Talent

In the digital age, technology skills have become essential for a wide range of professions. From marketing to programming, by way of project management or data analysis, many professionals try to keep up with the latest tools and technologies to secure their relevance in the job market. According to…

In the digital era, technology skills have become essential for a wide range of professions. From marketing to programming, project management or data analysis, many professionals seek to keep up with the latest tools and technologies to secure their relevance in the labor market.

According to the ‘The Future of Jobs 2023’ report from the World Economic Forum, 44% of workers' skills will need to be updated over the next five years because of digital transformation and automation.

With the growing demand for technical skills, a trend has also emerged among some professionals to “catch” certifications or superficial knowledge of emerging technologies and then sell themselves as experts, even though their real level of competence is limited.

We see individuals trying to “catch” skills to show off on their résumé or professional profile. Instead of developing deep competence in a specific area, many seek to quickly acquire a collection of skills without enough time to master them.

This phenomenon, which we call the “Pokémon effect”, is not new and has been studied before. A study by DevSkiller in 2023 found that 70% of software developers overestimate their skills in at least one key technology, which supports the idea of the effect in the technology industry. In articles we have shared previously, such as «The human factor in technology adoption» (June 2021) and «Embrace social networks, but don't sleep with them» (July 2016), we analyzed how the pressure to quickly adopt emerging technologies has created gaps in the real adoption of deep skills.

The result is a growing number of professionals who call themselves «experts» or «senior» when their actual level of experience is intermediate or, in some cases, basic.

The overvaluation of IT talent

One of the most worrying effects of this trend is the overvaluation of junior professionals. With the spread of online learning platforms, fast certifications and self-management tools, it is easier and easier to acquire basic skills in technical areas.

As a result, many junior professionals manage to enter the labor market with limited knowledge while presenting themselves as having more experience. This may look positive for the individuals, since it lets them get jobs faster, but it creates several long-term problems for both employers and team development.

When juniors sell themselves as seniors, companies can end up hiring people who are not truly qualified to take on the responsibilities the position requires. This sets off a chain of problems, from lower quality of work to delays in key projects, along with frustration among the staff who do have experience.

According to the ‘Global Knowledge IT Skills and Salary Report’, 76% of IT leaders report a critical skills gap in their departments, with the greatest shortage in senior and specialized roles.

The result is a labor market full of people who are not prepared for the positions they hold, which makes it harder and harder for employers to identify true senior professionals.

The shortage of «senior» IT talent

The overvaluation of junior professionals also has a negative impact on the true experts, the senior professionals who have actually developed a high level of competence. As more people without enough experience start to fill positions that require high levels of skill, true seniors become scarcer and harder to identify.

This not only affects opportunities for these experts, but also creates a void in companies, which cannot find the right talent to lead and guide teams.

The lack of clarity about who really has senior skills creates confusion for recruiters and work teams alike. In some cases, companies may avoid hiring people who present themselves as seniors, for fear of having been misled before, which creates a negative perception of the available talent in general. This dynamic affects the entire labor ecosystem, since the absence of truly competent professionals in strategic positions limits the growth and success of long-term projects.

Impact on hiring culture

The “Pokémon effect” among professionals also influences hiring culture. Companies, pressed by the need for digital talent, tend to focus on the number of certifications rather than on hands-on experience.

In fact, recent statistics on IT skills shortages show that cybersecurity and big data analytics are the areas most affected by the lack of talent with real experience, according to chief information officers (CIO) surveyed worldwide for the Digital Leadership Report by 2021. Hiring platforms should therefore adjust their assessments to prioritize demonstrated skills over the superficial accumulation of knowledge.

This has led to a shift in selection strategies, where the number of certifications or courses a candidate has completed is valued more than their hands-on experience or their ability to solve real problems in the workplace.

In addition, companies risk overpaying for junior talent that cannot meet the expectations set during the hiring process. In some cases, these junior professionals may end up in key positions, which creates distrust among more experienced employees who see people with less technical or strategic ability rewarded disproportionately.

A Korn Ferry study projects that by 2030, the shortage of technology talent could result in lost revenue of $8.5 trillion globally, underscoring the importance of addressing the ‘Pokémon effect’ in skills development.

Solutions to mitigate the “Pokémon effect”

To counter the “Pokémon effect” in professional development and hiring dynamics, companies must take a series of measures that let them better identify real talent and avoid the trap of hiring people who have only «caught» superficial skills.

  1. Assessment based on real experience: Companies should adopt selection processes that focus on assessing practical skills. This can include technical tests, simulations of work scenarios, or evaluations based on past projects. That makes it easier to determine whether a candidate truly masters the skills they claim to have, instead of relying only on a résumé or certifications.
  2. Promote clear development paths: Organizations need to foster a culture of continuous learning, one that values long-term development paths over the rapid accumulation of certifications. Employees should be encouraged to deepen their areas of specialization instead of chasing every new technology trend.
  3. Mentoring and senior leadership: Companies must make sure they have genuine senior leaders who can guide junior professionals. Mentoring is a key tool for helping employees develop deeper skills and avoid the temptation to jump prematurely into positions of greater responsibility without the necessary experience.
  4. Clearly define expectations for senior roles: Organizations must clearly define what it means to be a «senior» in terms of skills, responsibilities, and experience. This will help avoid confusion in the hiring process and allow professionals with the right experience to be recognized and rewarded for their true value.

A human dynamic

The «Pokémon effect» does not affect only companies in their frantic pursuit of the latest technologies; it also affects individuals in their professional development and the hiring dynamics of the labor market.

As more people try to appear to have a higher skill level than they really do, the valuation of junior talent becomes distorted and truly competent senior professionals grow increasingly scarce.

To mitigate this phenomenon, we recommend that companies adopt more rigorous selection strategies, promote long-term development, and recognize the value of true experts on their teams.

Remember that even Sir Richard Branson, founder of Virgin Group, shared on social media that companies should «train their people well enough so they can leave, and treat them well enough so they don't want to». In other words, the bell does not ring only on the Pokémon master's side.

The «Pokémon effect» is mitigated by enabling a level of maturity in the relationship with IT talent.