Generative AI «has no value»

The recent statement by Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella on the lack of tangible value generated by generative artificial intelligence is a call for restraint in an ecosystem where the technology narrative tends to be dominated by exaggeration and speculation. His claim that the true measure of AI's success…

The recent statement by Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella on the lack of tangible value generated by generative artificial intelligence is a call for restraint in an ecosystem where the technology narrative tends to be dominated by exaggeration and speculation.

His claim that the true measure of AI's success should be 10% economic growth worldwide rings with an uncomfortable truth: we have not yet seen the promised benefits of the AI revolution at scale.

This cautious stance clashes with Microsoft's own actions: it has invested more than 12 billion dollars in OpenAI and is a pillar of the ambitious Stargate Project, an initiative that seems to bet on a disruptive future for AI.

That leaves us with a strategic dissonance: while Nadella seeks to curb excessive speculation, Microsoft keeps investing aggressively in developing advanced models.

From the perspective of digitalization and the global economy, this debate is not new. In various analyses, we have addressed how adopting technology without a clear strategy can create inflated expectations that do not translate into real economic benefits.

AI, like any other emerging technology, needs clear impact metrics beyond the enthusiasm of its promoters.

What Microsoft faces now is the dilemma of every technological innovation: how do you justify massive investments when the results are not yet evident?

In economies like ours, where digitalization advances in a fragmented way, this kind of reflection should serve as a reminder that technology alone does not create value; it is its integration into effective business models that determines its impact.

The debate on the real usefulness of AI should not focus only on the performance of models such as ChatGPT, CoPilot and others, but on how they can be integrated into productive sectors to generate efficiency, jobs and sustainable development.

Otherwise, we risk continuing to feed a cycle of inflated expectations that, when they fail to materialize, erode confidence in the transformative potential of the technology.

Consider that only 1% of businesses worldwide, according to McKinsey, have managed to adopt this technology successfully. What can we leave for the rest?

I understand it is time to recognize that there are many smokescreens behind the commercialization of AI, and that this calls on organizations to strengthen, from their governance bodies, their strategic understanding of this technology.

Nadella is «praying to God, but swinging the hammer»…