Data, democracy and us (the People)
We are at a unique moment in human history: the growing battleground of digital sovereignty centers on citizen data. At the recent Data Governance Forum titled Regulation 4 Innovation, policymakers and global experts took part in a critical dialogue on the intersection between data governance,…

We are at a unique moment in human history: the growing battlefield of digital sovereignty centers on citizen data.
At the recent Data Governance Forum, titled Regulation 4 Innovation, policymakers and global experts took part in a critical dialogue on the intersection of data governance, democracy and citizens' rights. The discussion revealed a growing consensus: we are witnessing the most significant shift of power in the history of humanity, with data at its center.
Authoritative voices from more than 20 countries gathered at the World Summit Awards 2025, held in the city of Hyderabad, India. This year the event focuses on digital democracy, with the support of the government of Telangana and entrepreneurs affiliated with the T-Hub initiative.
What is the World Summit Awards?
The World Summit Awards (WSA) is a global initiative that recognizes and promotes digital innovations with a positive impact on society, in line with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), and encourages youth entrepreneurship around the world.
This unique awards system began in 2003 within the framework of the United Nations World Summit on the Information Society (United Nations WSIS).
The reality of data wars
One of the most striking revelations came from Rodrigo Assumpcao, Brazil's delegate, who stated plainly: «There are places, and Brazil is one of them, where we are having data wars». His example of farm machinery sending real-time planting data to U.S. manufacturers illustrates how collecting data has become more profitable than the raw materials being produced. These companies can «predict the harvest six months in advance and speculate on the futures market», generating wealth through data rather than tangible goods.
This represents a fundamental change in power dynamics. As Peter Bruck, Chairman of the WSA, emphasized, «Data is not a technical issue. Today, data is a question of power». It is about economic alignment, breaking up monopolies, antitrust efforts and, ultimately, ownership—with data sovereignty at its core.
Smartphones alone send personal data to at least four different entities every second. As Assumpcao noted, «One country in the world is collecting 10 times more data than the rest of the world combined. It is not paying a cent for it». This asymmetry creates what some participants called «digital colonialism» or, more specifically, «datacolonialism», where powerful entities extract value from citizens without compensation or consent.
The dangers of profiling by Big Tech
The forum addressed growing concerns about how technology companies profile users. Every interaction with digital platforms feeds into comprehensive profiles that can be monetized in ways invisible to users. As Dorothy Gordon, Ghana's delegate, noted, «They have a profile of you as an adult. They are tracking someone from the age of five until they are 20. They know exactly how to manipulate them».
Gordon stressed that while EU regulations may protect European citizens, those protections do not extend globally—not even to neighboring countries. When the Dutch government demanded that Google correct certain elements of how children's data was being used, «They changed them, but they did not change them even for the United Kingdom. They did not change them even for Belgium, which is right next door».
Participants also highlighted the interplay between big tech and governments. As one speaker noted, the attendance of tech leaders at political inaugurations shows that they understand their existence depends on government relationships, even as they operate at an unprecedented global scale.
Government control of user data: a crisis of trust
A particularly revealing moment came from an Iraqi participant who expressed greater trust in private companies handling his data than in his own government, noting that, in Iraq, «there are 20 intelligence organizations that hold your data, and they could have my data on the dark web, through Telegram channels with no accountability».
This crisis of trust is not limited to developing nations. Even in countries with robust regulatory frameworks, implementation often falls short. As Ieva Zilioniene of Lithuania observed, «In countries where people in general… trust our governments, we are quite fine with our data [being used] because the requirement is that I know why my data will be used».
Rakshita Swamy of India provided powerful examples of how government technologies meant to reduce corruption have ironically been used to justify withholding funds from states allegedly implementing programs corruptly, effectively «hitting» poor citizens twice—first with inadequate digital systems and then with the withholding of benefits they are entitled to.
Profiling children: programming the future
Perhaps most alarming was the discussion of how tech companies profile children from an early age. Dorothy Gordon warned that when companies collect data on children from age five into adulthood, they essentially hold a blueprint for manipulation.
The forum heard about the urgency of protecting children's data, with participants noting that education systems around the world are being “saturated” with technology of unproven benefit but significant data-collection capabilities. As Gordon put it, «We are spending enormous amounts of money on EdTech that is also being platformized».
This focus on children represents a long-term strategy by tech companies. By building complete profiles early, these companies potentially gain unprecedented influence over future voters, consumers and citizens.
The hierarchy of data control
Osama Manzar, founder of the Digital Empowerment Foundation, set out a hierarchical framework for understanding the data governance challenge: «There is technology, then there is policy, then there is partisan politics, and then there is intent».
This hierarchy explains why identical technology can lead to radically different outcomes depending on the policy framework, the political environment and the intentions behind its implementation. As Manzar illustrated with the example of rural workers required to verify their attendance digitally despite not having smartphones: «Technology cannot be blamed, which is absolutely true… Technology says that, for efficiency, I am collecting data… But you know that 95% of people do not own a smartphone, they do not know how to use it, yet they are asked to mark attendance».
The intention behind deploying technology often reveals whether it really serves citizens or simply extends control. As Tanya Wehsely, a delegate from Austria, aptly said, «If you put garbage in, you get garbage out», highlighting how the quality and intent behind data collection directly affect the results.
Regulation for innovation
The title of the forum, Regulation 4 Innovation, represented a deliberate rethinking of the traditional view that regulation impedes innovation. As Peter Bruck noted, we need «to make sure that this usual opposition, the idea that regulation is bad for innovation, dissolves».
Participants offered several avenues to pursue:
- Data ownership reform: All governments regulate that data belongs to the owner of the device. Not to the device manufacturer, not to the company that makes the device's software.
- Transparency requirements: Dorothy Gordon called for clarity on «which technology and which company is involved in delivering e-government services».
- Rights-based approaches: Ensuring that digital systems remain «subordinate to the law, due process and the constitution», as Swamy advocated.
- Grassroots organization: Communities developing their own data governance policies and structures.
- Educational initiatives: UNESCO's work on AI ethics education and readiness assessments in 60 countries around the world.
The fundamental challenge remains balancing innovation with the public interest to create an inclusive and responsible digital future. As UNESCO's Eunsong Kim noted, «Many countries… see regulation not as being for innovation, but as an obstruction to innovation».
In this new era of data wars and the phenomenon of digital colonialism, the stakes could not be higher.
I want to conclude this account as a spectator of the forum with Peter Bruck's closing words, since we are experiencing «the greatest shift of power ever seen in human history in terms of how to shape the future».