India's Personal Data Protection Act: Privacy Shield or Threat to Democracy?

We recently had the privilege of taking part in the World Summit Awards 2025 held in Hyderabad, India, where these very issues were discussed. A special session set off international alarms about the future of privacy and democracy in the digital age. The reason: the critical analysis of the Data Protection Act…

Recently, we had the privilege of taking part in the World Summit Awards 2025 held in Hyderabad, India, where these very issues were discussed. A special session set off international alarms about the future of privacy and democracy in the digital age.

The reason: a critical analysis of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act (DPDP Act) recently enacted by the Indian government.

The session, led by prominent activists and journalists such as Nikhil Dey and Sangeeta Barua, not only exposed the weaknesses of this legislation but also showed the dangerous precedent it could set for other emerging democracies —including the Dominican Republic— if this model is adopted without critical scrutiny.

An opaque legislative process with no debate

One of the most worrying aspects of the DPDP Act is the way it was passed: without parliamentary debate, amid political protests over ethnic violence in Manipur. This “strange secrecy” —as Barua called it— shut dissenting voices out of the democratic process, depriving citizens of a legitimate space to discuss a law that affects the lives of millions of people.

This phenomenon is not unique to India. In many emerging economies, technology laws move forward without adequate mechanisms for public consultation or transparency, which feeds the fear that digital power will end up concentrated in the hands of governments with little commitment to democracy.

The destruction of the right to information (RTI)

The core of the criticism of the DPDP Act is its devastating impact on the Right to Information (RTI), a vital tool for fighting corruption and demanding accountability from the Indian state. Nikhil Dey explained how the new law amends section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, removing the clause that allowed personal information to be disclosed whenever it related to a public activity or a collective interest.

This means that key information —such as who built a road, who received public funds or who appears on a voter list— could now be considered “personal” and therefore inaccessible. The consequence is clear: citizens are weakened in the face of political and economic power.

Journalism under threat

One of the sectors most vulnerable to the DPDP Act is investigative journalism. Barua warned that reporters will be forced to ask permission from individuals —including corrupt people or criminals— before publishing identifiable data. This is a direct blow to press freedom and to the essential role of the media in watching over power.

In Nikhil Dey's words: “From now on, journalism will not be possible”. The collection and processing of public data —including investigations such as the Pegasus case— would be curtailed by the new legal limits, affecting the flow of truthful and timely information.

Another troubling element of the law is the unlimited power it gives the central government to request information from any data fiduciary. This power, based on section 36, opens the door to mass surveillance and arbitrary control over companies, citizens and media outlets.

In addition, the financial penalties are astronomical. Fines can reach 250 crore rupees (about 30 million dollars), a figure out of reach for most journalists or activists. This creates a climate of fear and self-censorship, in which questioning power can carry a ruinous cost.

The call for global action

The WSA panelists issued an urgent call for social and international mobilization. They proposed taking the debate to global forums such as the United Nations World Press Freedom Day and launching petition campaigns to stop the implementation of the DPDP Act.

They warned that, if this law is consolidated without opposition, it could be exported to other countries under the false premise of protecting privacy, when in reality it conceals a design for state control and the restriction of fundamental rights.

Contrast with the Dominican reality: are we prepared?

In the Dominican Republic, the debate on personal data protection is only beginning to take hold on the public agenda. Although Law No. 172-13 on the Protection of Personal Data exists, its scope is limited and it lacks a comprehensive approach to the challenges of today's digital economy.

Unlike India, our Caribbean country has not yet seen reforms that undermine access to public information or the practice of journalism. In fact, the General Law on Free Access to Public Information (2004) remains a vital instrument for citizens, journalists and civil society organizations.

Even so, this should not lead us to complacency. The lack of digital culture, limited knowledge of citizens' rights online and institutional weaknesses could open the door to regressive reforms inspired by authoritarian models disguised as modernity.

The lesson from India's experience is clear: data protection laws must emerge from a broad, plural and democratic dialogue. They cannot become tools of censorship or control. They must be effective guarantees that protect privacy without sacrificing the right to information and government transparency.

The future of privacy and democracy

The battle over personal data is also a battle for democracy. In an increasingly digital world, privacy protection cannot be an excuse to consolidate opaque powers or silence critical voices.

The Dominican Republic has the opportunity —and the responsibility— to watch closely what is happening elsewhere and to anticipate the risks. The challenge is to build a digital governance model that combines respect for individual rights with the preservation of a vibrant, participatory democratic ecosystem.

Because in the end, as Sangeita Barua reminded us in Hyderabad: ““Who does this law protect in the name of my privacy? The citizen or those in power?”” — That is the question we must also ask ourselves, here and now.