State of Technology in the Dominican Republic

Over the last twenty years, the Dominican Republic has experienced notable economic growth, one of the fastest in the region. This progress is due to a mix of pro-market structural reforms established in the 1990 and favorable external conditions, which were complemented by prudent monetary and fiscal policies that ensured macroeconomic stability. This significant growth, however,…

Over the last twenty years, the Dominican Republic has experienced remarkable economic growth, one of the fastest in the region. This progress stems from a mix of pro-market structural reforms established in the 1990 and favorable external conditions, which were complemented with prudent monetary and fiscal policies that ensured a macroeconomic stability.

This significant growth, however, faces current challenges. According to the World Bank (WB), the country's productivity has shown slow growth, hindered -among other reasons- by the lack of skilled human capital to meet the demands of the business sector, the impact of climate change and distortions in key markets, including the inefficient distribution of tax exemptions.

It was forecast that the country's economic growth would slow down in 2023, falling from 4.9 percent the previous year to 3.1. This despite a slight decline in the poverty rate  -21 percent in 2023 compared with 23 in 2020- this figure remains higher than pre-pandemic levels. 

This growth has not led to the creation of quality jobs in several sectors, and the high inflation rate of 8.8 percent annually in 2022 has negatively affected the population, particularly the most vulnerable.

Data from the WB Group reveal shortcomings in access to quality basic services such as education, health, water and electricity. These factors are essential to expand economic opportunities, improve economic mobility and protect the most vulnerable sectors. 

Because of the impacts of climate change and economic crises, more than 40 percent of Dominicans live in vulnerable conditions and are at risk of falling into poverty. 

In addition, the growing exposure to natural disasters -intensified by climate change- threatens to increase the country's contingent fiscal liabilities. On top of this come gender disparities in employment and wages, along with a shorter working life and a higher unemployment rate and more unpaid roles among women, which contribute to a higher incidence of poverty in this demographic group.

Looking ahead, to achieve inclusive and sustainable growth, the Dominican Republic must improve its productivity. This can be achieved not only by applying technology effectively, but also through reforms focused on strengthening human capital, competitiveness, uninterrupted innovation, efficiency of public spending and resilience to climate events.

Beyond local paradigms

The Latin America and Caribbean (LAC) region achieved significant progress in macroeconomic resilience over the last three decades, providing greater resilience against shocks such as rising inflationary pressures, global uncertainty, rising debt and low commodity prices, along with the convergence of poverty and employment levels to pre-pandemic levels.

The report «Digital Connectivity for Inclusion and Growth» by the WB predicted that regional Gross Domestic Product (GDP) will grow by two percent in 2023, slightly above the 1.4 percent projected earlier, but still below that of every other region in the world.

Growth rates of 2.3 and 2.6 percent are expected for 2024 and 2025, respectively. These rates -similar to those of the decade 2010- are not enough to achieve the much-needed progress in inclusion and poverty reduction.

Countries such as the Dominican Republic must find ways to promote inclusion and growth, improve governance and build social consensus. Digital solutions can play a crucial role in addressing these challenges. Improved digital connectivity, together with complementary policies, offers the opportunity to foster more dynamic and inclusive societies.

A decade of telecommunications growth

The Dominican Republic has seen significant progress in the telecommunications sector over the last decade, with substantial growth in digital infrastructure and widespread adoption of communication technologies.

From 2013 to 2023, the population grew by approximately 10 percent, from 9,785,000 to 10,760,028 according to the Dominican Institute of Telecommunications (INDOTEL) and the National Statistics Office (ONE). 

During this period, the shift toward digital communication became evident, with a decline in landlines, from 1,095,420 to 649,875. 

Even so, pay-TV accounts have grown notably, from 464,929 to 737,243. Mobile phone subscriptions have also risen, from 9,059,820 to 10,283,652.

World Bank data complement this picture, highlighting that -for 2021- 85% of the population used the internet, a substantial increase from just four percent who did so in 2000. 

In 2022, mobile phone subscriptions reached a rate of 90 per 100 people, exceeding the 82% of 2020. In addition, fixed broadband subscriptions have increased significantly, with 10.68 subscriptions per 100 people in 2022, up from 7.99% in 2018.

To analyze the state of current technology, our cross-cutting measurement platform must be the Internet, where we see the most notable progress in the number of access accounts, which have nearly tripled, from 3,588,024 to 10,040,356, and in the number of internet users, which has more than doubled, from 4,491,315 to 9,081,464.

We always point out that we must avoid public-policy bias when addressing the internet access accounts metric, because many internet access accounts are used by ATMs, security cameras and other electronic devices. 

In this regard, internet protocol (IP) lines have grown exponentially, from 76,008 to 496,763, showing in some way the sophistication of businesses at the connectivity level.

This sustained growth in access to and use of telecommunications shows rapid digitalization of Dominican society and a commitment to improving mobile and internet connectivity, which is essential for economic and social progress. 

The challenge for populations is affordability, which is where the “usage gap” appears: the distance between what is physically feasible (as determined by the capacity of current devices) and the actual connectivity observed in many countries  in the LAC region. 

Around 38 percent of the population (240 million people) lives in areas with coverage but chooses not to access the Internet, according to  the GSM Association (GSMA).

Investment in communications infrastructure and adaptation to global trends in digital connectivity are making this impressive development possible, and they promise to keep transforming the lives of Dominicans.

Digital development

The country's electronic services market currently faces several important trends and problems, including the emergence of new technologies, rising consumer demand for digital services, and the disruption of traditional business models. These have had a positive impact on the electronic services market, which has led to growth in revenue, market share, and consumer adoption. 

Revenue in the electronic services market is expected to reach 82,65 million dollars in 2023, recording growth of 20.7 percent compared with 2022. In addition, the emergence of new technologies has allowed companies to offer more innovative digital services, while consumer demand has driven greater competition in the market.

Going forward, the electronic services market is likely to keep growing strongly. As more companies adopt digital services and new technologies emerge, consumer demand for them is likely to keep driving market growth. 

It is also likely that traditional business models will continue to be disrupted, which will result in more innovation and opportunities for companies to take advantage of the digital economy.

Social media communication

Although the growth in the number of users on platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, Messenger, and LinkedIn is notable, it is important to stress that this growth is not a conclusive indicator of the country's effective digitalization.

According to recent data from the firm Tabuga, Facebook now has approximately 7.676.200 Dominican users, a significant increase from the estimate as of 2018 of 6 million users. 

Instagram has also seen impressive growth, with 4.797.500 users, doubling the estimated figure of 2 million in 2018. Although Twitter (renamed X in 2023) does not share public data, the platform is estimated to have one million users in the country.

On the other hand, LinkedIn, the social network oriented to the professional and business world, has seen a considerable increase in its user base, reaching one million 662 thousand members. This growth reflects the dynamism of the labor market and the importance of the network as a space for high-level companies —and particularly those linked to the technology sector— to spread their messages and job opportunities.

LinkedIn has established itself as a valuable resource for connecting professionals and the corporate world in the Dominican Republic, showing the rapid progress in digitalization and the adoption of online tools for business and personal communication.

However, the increase in the use of digital devices does not by itself guarantee the elimination of the digital divide. Rather, it introduces new challenges, such as gaps in connectivity, content, user experience, support, and regulation.

Even so, overall we understand that we have grown because the Internet has been the door that has made closer contact and technological connection with Dominicans possible.

Digital media

Driven by the expansion of mobile Internet access and rising connection speeds, the growing number of mobile and streaming devices is leading to steady growth in demand for all kinds of digital media. 

The big change in the market can be attributed to the COVID pandemic-19, which caused an unusual increase in demand for media and in the need for digitalization.

This positive effect generated more growth, but it was to be expected that digital media would remain predominant even after the pandemic. For 2023, projected revenue in the digital media market in the Dominican Republic was expected to reach 25.50 million dollars, which represents growth of 10.9% compared with 2022.

Video on demand (“on demand”) is especially expected to continue on its growth path, with Netflix currently the biggest player in the territory. However, according to forecasts, Disney+ will become the most popular streaming service for 2026. Going forward, improved technology and new ways of consuming media will align with users' growing consumption and show steady growth.

The challenge for the platforms is the tax debate and the claim of unfair competition from the “over the top” (OTT) services against telephone operators. This is because markets such as digital video and digital music are seeing an increase in the number of competitors and variation between regions, which has produced a series of strategic alliances that address the complaint of the sector already established in the country.

Data: a link in Dominican technological development

With each emerging technology that appears in the company, both the organization and the key actor who wants to apply it have to undertake a vertical development. In that sense, the first step must be to obtain the essential data to enable the systems.

A specific example would be mapping a region, which has to be based on geopositioning data. Thanks to technologies such as Google Maps and public-domain resources, companies can start from that existing base. 

On the other hand, there are other aspects that must be developed across the entire value chain and, if we monitor industry by industry, we see that this is precisely the main pain point for applying technologies in the country.

The authorities must continue down the path of open data. I would like to note in passing that the Dominican Republic is a signatory to the open data agreement. 

Data is an “Achilles' heel” for local innovation. In the Global Innovation Index 2023, the data relating to the Dominican Republic appears to be outdated across multiple indicators.

For example, school life expectancy, tertiary enrollment and graduates in science and engineering are based on figures from 2017, updated only in 2020. Likewise, the data on electricity production and on firms offering formal training come from 2020 and 2016, respectively.

This lag in data collection and reporting raises concerns about the reliability and relevance of the country's innovation rankings in the current context.

The absence of up-to-date statistics could also hide the most recent progress or challenges in the country's innovation landscape, which makes it harder for policymakers, researchers and business leaders to make informed decisions.

It is crucial to be able to obtain and analyze data in order to understand more precisely where the Dominican Republic stands in fostering an innovative environment, and to avoid the vicious circle of designing policy with outdated or -even worse- nonexistent data.

The information we find in the open data model that the government provides through the site datos.gob.do shares what the State does.

The country's behavior should be collected and recorded so that this data can be shared with young people in schools -for educational purposes-  with universities for scientific purposes, with neighborhood associations so that it helps them build a citizen reflection and with business associations to improve their businesses.

The data revolution is necessary so that Dominicans can begin to reflect and then develop predictive models. I will not tire of repeating it: what our country lacks are credible, reliable sources of up-to-date information, not merely technologies.

The fundamental principle for the proper functioning of Big Data, Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence requires that data be actionable.

Without data we will not have truly useful AI

Our reflection on developing artificial intelligence models concerns the paramount importance of the data set, or “dataset» in determining a model's behavior. 

A post written by James Betker, an OpenAI engineer (better known as JBetker) observes that, despite the variety of configurations and hyperparameter settings, all large language models tend to converge toward similar results after sufficient training on the same data set.

This observation supports the notion that the «dataset» is the most critical factor, above the model architecture, hyperparameters or optimization choices.                               

The models are, in essence, approximating their data sets to an impressive degree, which means they learn the patterns and intrinsic frequencies of the data more than anything else. 

This implies that models end up reflecting the qualities of the «dataset», including possible biases or limitations inherent in the data they were trained on.

So, rather than having an Artificial Intelligence Strategy for the country, which –in fact– we already have, and under which AI models such as «LaMDA», «ChatGPT», «Bard» or «Claude» can be applied, in reality what we should be doing is talking about the underlying «dataset» and not about a specific model.

This underscores the premise that the quality and composition of training data are fundamental to building effective, reliable AI models, and that any training strategy or clever trick is secondary to the quality of the «dataset».

Moreover, reflection and conversation should lead us to the conclusion that we skipped a national data strategy that could have been supported by the National Open Data Commission. 

This consonance resonates with a concept known as «the bitter lesson» in AI, which posits that progress in this field is driven more by methods that leverage large amounts of data and compute than by those that depend on human insights encoded in the model's design or hyperparameters.

In short, data instead of code.