From structural vision to scalable action

In 2009, the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) published a revealing document: “República Dominicana: Una revisión de la ciencia, tecnología e innovación”. At the time, the approach was clear —and necessary—: to strengthen the structural foundations of a national innovation system through long-term reforms, public investment in R&D, and support for…

In 2009, the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) published a revealing document: “Dominican Republic: A Review of Science, Technology and Innovation”. At that time, the approach was clear —and necessary—: to strengthen the structural foundations of a national innovation system through long-term reforms, public investment in R&D, support for higher education, and robust institutions that could bring together productive and scientific capacities. As a country, we were at an incipient stage, where thinking about the “digital economy” was still an exercise in foresight.

That IDB study served as a critical diagnosis and a compass for public policy. It identified the limitations of the Dominican institutional environment for science and technology: low state investment (less than 0.25% of GDP), weak university-business ties, and a feeble capacity in the institutions responsible for promoting innovation. From that base, it proposed a long-term path, with the State as planner, regulator and key investor to close the existing gaps.

Today, fifteen years later, I can say with data in hand that we have covered part of the road, but also that the world has changed faster than our institutions. Digitalization has not waited for our structures to finish maturing. On the contrary, it has pushed in from the edges, forcing public and private actors to react. In this context, I wrote the book Economía Digital: Motor de Cambio para la República Dominicana (Digital Economy: Engine of Change for the Dominican Republic), in which I gather the evidence of real progress, the new opportunities and the challenges that remain in the current digital decade.

A new horizon: from the long term to what scales

The first major difference between the IDB's vision (2009) and the reality I describe in my book is the time horizon. The structural approach, which expected results in 15 or 20 years, has been overtaken by a technological dynamic that demands answers in the short and medium term. We can no longer expect policies to take decades to mature. Entrepreneurs, small and medium-sized enterprises, digital consumers and new business models need immediate actions that can scale.

In 2022, we estimate that the size of the Dominican digital economy represents approximately 5.85% of national GDP, a significant jump from the 4.31% baseline, which we estimated at 2020, and much closer to the global average estimated by UNCTAD for 2017 (between 4.5% and 15.5%). This figure tells us that growth is not a future promise: it is already happening.

Sectoral intervention versus structural public policy

Another critical point of contrast is the level of intervention. While the IDB called for strengthening structural public policies, from my perspective and field experience, the most effective path has been to activate specific sectors with high potential for impact. I am referring to the five key digital markets I identified in the book: electronic services (eServices), digital media, Fintech, digital advertising and e-commerce.

For example, the Fintech market alone generated more than 3,200 million dollars in revenue in 2022, while e-commerce accounted for 1,563 million dollars that same year. These figures, backed by data gathered in our sector reports, show how sectoral intervention, combined with good digital infrastructure and adaptable human capital, can overcome the limitations of traditional policies.

However, this transition toward agile sectoral interventions poses a fundamental methodological challenge: how do we ensure that immediate actions do not compromise the coherence of the digital ecosystem in the long term?

International experience suggests that the most successful countries in digital transformation have managed to combine rapid responses with adaptive governance frameworks. Estonia, for example, developed its e-Residency program as a specific sectoral response, but it did so on a solid digital institutional base built over decades.

In our Dominican context, this means developing what we might call «architectures of coherence»: light but effective institutional mechanisms that ensure sectoral interventions reinforce one another rather than compete for resources or create contradictory regulatory frameworks. One concrete example would be to set up an intersectoral committee that assesses the cross-impact of new Fintech regulations on e-commerce, or vice versa.

The State: from regulator to strategic facilitator

The IDB report saw the Dominican State as planner, regulator and investor. That view, though valid at a foundational moment, now requires an evolution. The speed of change demands that the State act as a facilitator and strategic ally. This means creating the conditions for the digital ecosystem to flourish: simplifying regulation, promoting private investment, and updating the tax framework for digital platforms, without stifling innovation.

The reality is that many of the digital services operating in the country —such as Netflix, Uber and Airbnb, among others— do so without clear regulation, without paying taxes locally in an efficient way, and with business models that exceed the current capacities of our tax legislation. In the book I discuss how initiatives such as the attempt to apply ITBIS to digital services must be handled from a comprehensive, consensus-based perspective, not merely an administrative one.

Measuring impact: beyond academia

Impact evaluation also marks a key difference between the two approaches. The IDB measured progress in terms of institutional and educational capacities, such as the number of researchers, scientific publications or investment in universities. By contrast, I propose a measurement based on digital income generation, employment, financial inclusion and consumer well-being.

I even introduce the concept of GDP-B (Gross Domestic Product of Well-being), inspired by MIT studies, as an indicator that captures the real value citizens obtain from free digital goods and services. In a country where millions of Dominicans use services such as WhatsApp, email, YouTube or Google Maps, it is unacceptable that this economic value is not counted in our national metrics.

GDP-B in practice

The GDP-B concept (Gross Domestic Product of Well-being) that I propose is based on the methodology developed by Erik Brynjolfsson and Avinash Collis of MIT, but adapted to the realities of Dominican digital consumption. The measurement would be carried out through three main components:

Component 1: Value of free services by time of use Using willingness-to-pay surveys, we estimate that the average Dominican would value WhatsApp at approximately $15 per month, Google Maps at $8, and YouTube at $12. Considering that 78% of the population has access to mobile internet, this represents an uncounted added value of approximately $2,400 million per year.

Component 2: Savings in transaction costs Digital services reduce traditional costs. For example, a digital bank transfer versus a physical one saves an average of $3.50 per transaction. With 89 million digital transactions per year, this represents $311 million in direct savings for consumers.

Component 3: Value of social and professional connectivity Using social network analysis models, we calculate the economic value of the digital connections that enable job, business, and social opportunities. Implementing the GDP-B would require collaboration among the Ministry of Economy, the Central Bank, and the ONE to develop a data collection methodology that is consistent and internationally comparable.

An unavoidable transition

This is not a criticism of the IDB's approach, but an acknowledgment that it was a first cornerstone along the way. What I am arguing is that this model must be updated. Startups do not wait for a ten-year plan to be approved. The cloud, artificial intelligence, mobile payments, and digital platforms are already here. The digital economy is no longer a promise; it is a reality. And our institutional framework has to run to catch up with it.

That is why, from Tabuga and other initiatives such as Startups Academy, we continue to promote an ecosystem that favors action, data, and impact. We cannot keep measuring digital development in terms of policies that never reach the ground. We must measure it in opportunities created, in digital businesses that export, in young people who join the global economy from a laptop in Baní or Santiago.

Navigating the risks of sectoral specialization

The sectoral intervention strategy, though effective, carries risks that we must anticipate and mitigate:

  • Risk of regulatory fragmentation: When different government agencies develop regulatory frameworks for specific sectors without coordination, contradictions can arise. In the Dominican Republic, we have seen this in the tensions between the Superintendency of Banks' regulations for Fintech and those of the Ministry of Industry for e-commerce.
  • Inequities in access to incentives: Sectoral targeting can create distortions in which «favored» sectors (such as Fintech) receive more government support than other equally important ones (such as Agrotech or Healthtech). To mitigate this, I propose a «priority rotation» system in which sectoral priorities are evaluated and adjusted every three years based on social and economic impact metrics.
  • Dependence on sectoral champions: There is a risk that a sector's success depends excessively on a few leading companies. In our case, 60% of digital revenue is concentrated in five companies. This calls for specific policies to foster competition and diversification.
  • Comprehensive mitigation strategy: To address these risks, I propose implementing a «Digital Coherence Observatory» that would monitor cross-sector indicators, assess the distributional impact of sectoral policies, and recommend periodic adjustments to keep the ecosystem in balance.

With one foot in the future

The digitalization of the Dominican value chain can no longer wait. The IDB study of 2009 charted a valuable route, but the present demands new tools, new metrics, and a new attitude. It is not about replacing the structural vision, but complementing it with agility, data, and strategic collaboration. Today more than ever, the challenge is to move from plan to action, from institutional design to the real market, from potential to impact.

And for that, we must dare to think differently.

—

The book Economía Digital: motor de cambio para la República Dominicana, 2 edition, is available on Amazon and at economiadigital.do