Public entrepreneurs

In the Dominican Republic, the concept of “public entrepreneurs” has emerged as a seemingly logical strategy: the State taking an active role in promoting digital entrepreneurship and technological innovation. However, after years of watching these initiatives, a paradox emerges that is both fascinating and worrying: while these state interventions can strengthen small ecosystems…

In the Dominican Republic, the concept of “public entrepreneurs” has emerged as a seemingly logical strategy: the State takes an active role in promoting digital entrepreneurship and technological innovation. However, after years of watching these initiatives, a paradox emerges that is both fascinating and worrying: while these state interventions can strengthen small, specific ecosystems, they also limit the broad, inclusive development we so badly need.

The seduction of partial victories

The Dominican State has shown some ability to create “islands of excellence” when it focuses resources on specific sectors. The National Strategy for the Promotion of the Semiconductor Industry (ENFIS), established by Decree 324-24, is a emblematic example. With ambitious goals such as increasing STEM graduates by 50% by 2030 and setting up three specialized free-trade zones, this initiative has attracted significant investment, such as Eaton Corporation's R&D center in Santo Domingo, worth $3 billion.

Similarly, the National Strategy for the Export of Modern Services has shown tangible results, placing the country at position 24 globally in 2022 and 21 in 2023 in exports of creative products. These cases suggest that focused public entrepreneurship can have positive effects when it concentrates on well-defined areas.

But here lies the first problem: these partial victories create an illusion of success that hides deeper structural limitations.

Exclusivity disguised as inclusion

What we consistently observe is a restrictive model of access to opportunities that perpetuates the “recycling of the same actors” in public initiatives. Instead of fostering shared value, the approach centers on exclusivity, concentrating resources among established groups and limiting the participation of new entrepreneurs and the wider business community.

This dynamic produces what we could call “digital feudalism”: a few technology lords with privileged access to state resources, while the rest of the ecosystem stays on the margins.

The investment paradox

We keep prioritizing investment in tangible physical infrastructure over critical areas such as human capital, research and development, and intangible assets. This imbalance is evident in our R&D spending, which is less than 0.1% of GDP, significantly below regional averages.

One figure illustrates this paradox: while Artificial Intelligence is spoken of as a national priority, projected AI investment for 2024 was a mere US$10 million, a “negligible” amount compared with our GDP of more than $68 billion. This minimal investment condemns us to be perpetual consumers, never creators of technology.

“The invisibles”: talent that slips away from us

One of the most worrying phenomena is that of the “invisible” professionals: highly qualified Dominicans who, educated locally or abroad, emigrate or work remotely for international companies because of the lack of competitive opportunities at home.

An engineer trained in Santiago may end up developing behavior-measurement algorithms for a startup in Mexico without ever having had the chance to lead a similar project in his own country. These professionals become “invisible” to the national system, contributing minimally to local taxes while their skills are exported. It is the symptom of an ecosystem that works as a “talent factory” for the world, but systematically fails to retain its best human resources.

The brain drain is a direct consequence of a limited, uncompetitive ecosystem that cannot retain its talent, perpetuating a cycle of external dependence.

The dilemma worsens when that entrepreneur returns to the country and finds that, to reconnect with the ecosystem, the only viable option seems to be the one everyone else uses: becoming a government entrepreneur. It is an easy recipe on the surface, but it reproduces dependence and limits real innovation.

The “paper country” mindset

We persist with obsolete regulations and a “paper country” mindset, in which digital processes still require physical documentation and signatures to be legally valid. This stifles innovation and makes it harder for digital companies to formalize and operate efficiently.

Tax rules that classify foreign software and cloud services as taxable remittances or purchases from abroad (with taxes that can reach 40% of the original price) discourage digital adoption, especially among small and medium-sized businesses.

This tax burden penalizes local companies trying to compete with larger entities that can absorb these costs more easily, creating an artificial competitive disadvantage.

Strategies without real consultation

Initiatives such as the National Artificial Intelligence Strategy (ENIA) have drawn criticism for insufficient consultation periods and limited representation beyond technology companies, risking strategies designed for specific interests rather than broad social benefit.

The fragmentation of innovation variables highlights the absence of a coherent, multisectoral approach. This approach produces insufficient collaboration among universities, the private sector and government, limiting applied research and the creation of patents.

Despite the investments, the Dominican Republic has seen a significant decline in the Global Innovation Index (GII), falling from position 90 in 2020 to 97 in 2024, its lowest position since 2012. This points to structural problems stemming mainly from the imbalance toward physical infrastructure instead of human capital and research.

Toward a new paradigm: recommendations before consulting the GPT

1. Rebalance investments

We need a significant shift away from tangible infrastructure and toward human capital, education and research.

2. Democratize access and opportunities

Policies that open access to financing, technology and training for all entrepreneurs and SMEs, not just a select few.

3. Strengthen data governance

Establish a robust, transparent open-data system that is accessible and actionable.

4. Foster real multisector collaboration

Build solid alliances among government, the private sector and academia to co-create solutions to local problems.

5. Modernize regulatory frameworks

Review fiscal policies on software and cloud services, and create comprehensive data and cybersecurity regulations.

What future do we choose?

The current model of state-led entrepreneurship, although it shows potential in niche areas, inadvertently limits broader digital development because of its centralization, resource imbalance, lack of access to data, brain drain and regulatory obstacles.

Real transformation requires systemic change: from exclusivity to inclusion, from physical infrastructure to human capital, from fragmentation to collaboration. Only then can we turn our investments into genuine, widespread innovation.

The question is not whether the State should take part in entrepreneurship, but how it should do so to multiply opportunities instead of concentrating them. That answer will determine whether we remain a talent factory for the world or finally become the creators of our own technological destiny.

Today, looking at the recycling of actors and the repeated recipes, doubts about the model's sustainability are unavoidable. To be authentic, innovation cannot depend on being “connected” to the State, but on the ecosystem's capacity to  sustain itself  and grow on its own.