The Price of Complacency

Five years of decline in innovation: quantifying the cost of inaction on artificial intelligence and technological competitiveness. Complacency has a price. In the Dominican Republic, that price is measured in lost rankings, wasted opportunities and economic value systematically transferred to external technology ecosystems. Between 2020 and 2025, while we celebrated "progress" in headlines…

Five years of backsliding in innovation: quantifying the cost of inaction on artificial intelligence and technological competitiveness

Complacency has a price. In the case of the Dominican Republic, that price is measured in lost rankings, squandered opportunities and economic value systematically transferred to external technology ecosystems.

Between 2020 and 2025, while we celebrated «progress» in optimistic headlines, the country fell seven places in the Global Innovation Index (from 90 to 97) and three places in the Latin American Artificial Intelligence Index (from 6th to 9th). This is neither natural decline nor statistical fluctuation. It is the accumulated cost of years of strategies without execution, investments without return, and speeches without consequences.

What we have already lost

US$300 million a year in value transfer: According to Tabuga Intelligence, the Dominican Republic will spend more than US$300 million on AI during 2025, embedded as a layer within software distributed to private organizations. This spending is concentrated in machine learning for finance, e-commerce, cybersecurity and natural language processing. Practically all of this consumption is solutions developed abroad. The US$300 million leaves the country without generating local specialized jobs, without building endogenous capabilities, without creating Dominican intellectual property.

Emigrated specialized talent: While countries such as Chile, Brazil and Uruguay retain and attract technical talent with competitive pay and opportunities for applied research, the Dominican Republic works as a net exporter of machine learning engineers, data scientists and AI specialists. Each professional who emigrates represents not only lost educational investment, but decades of potential contribution to the local innovation ecosystem.

Opportunities captured by competitors: Mexico, Peru and Argentina—countries that have overtaken us in the ILIA 2025—are positioning themselves strategically to capture foreign direct investment in technology, develop regional innovation hubs, and export technology services. Every AI development contract won by a Mexican or Argentine company is a contract not won by a Dominican company that does not exist, because we did not create the ecosystem for it to be born.

Zero verifiable innovation outputs: The Dominican Republic ranks 138 of 139 in scientific and technical articles per billion PPP$ GDP, 135 of 139 in trademarks by origin, and 128 of 139 in industrial designs. We produce four patents a year in an economy of 11.4 million people. We have no universities in global rankings, no tech unicorns, no Dominican brands among the global top 5,000. Five years of institutional stagnation have cemented this reality: we spend but do not produce, we consume but do not innovate, we invest in inputs but do not generate outputs.

The documented decline

The Latin American Artificial Intelligence Index (ILIA) 2025, produced by ECLAC and Chile's National Center for Artificial Intelligence, confirms what many of us suspected: The Dominican Republic has fallen from sixth place in 2024 to ninth in 2025. Mexico, Peru and Argentina overtook us not because we collapsed but because they accelerated while we kept an insufficient incremental pace.

Our score of 44.96 out of 100, although above the regional average of 41 points, masks the fundamental problem: the gap is widening. Chile leads with 70.56 points—a difference of 25.6 points that represents not years but decades of institutional development that we would need to catch up at current speeds.

The Global Innovation Index (GII) 2025 presents an even more devastating diagnosis:

Trajectory 2020-2025:

  • 2020: Position 90
  • 2022: Position 90 (stagnation)
  • 2023: Position 94 (a drop of 4 places)
  • 2024-2025: Position 97 (stagnation and decline)

Seven positions lost in five years. Each position represents countries that invested more aggressively, executed better, coordinated effectively across government, academia and industry, and are now better positioned to attract investment, retain talent and generate technological value.

The paradox: investment without return

The Dominican Republic does not suffer from a lack of investment in education or infrastructure. The problem is conversion. The GII 2025 documents it brutally: «The Dominican Republic produces fewer innovation outputs relative to its level of investment in innovation inputs».

We invest in:

  • Education (4.3% of GDP, ranked 63 globally)
  • Connectivity (85% internet penetration)
  • Technical training (sustained growth in CS programs)
  • National AI Strategy (ENIA since October 2023)

But we produce:

  • Position 138/139 in scientific publications
  • Position 135/139 in trademarks
  • Position 128/139 in industrial designs
  • Position 106/139 in researchers per million inhabitants

This input-output disconnect is no accident. It is a symptom of deficient institutional allocation, nonexistent sectoral coordination, and counterproductive incentive design.

Consumption versus investment

The evolution of the AI ecosystem in the Dominican Republic reveals a structural asymmetry that explains the setback:

AI consumption (2025): US$300 million per year Investment in local development (2024): US$10 million Projected local investment (2030):US$738.77 million, according to Statista

Even if the optimistic projection of 2030 is reached, the disparity speaks for itself: in one year we consume (US$300M), which is what we project to invest in local development over several decades. This configuration consolidates us as a consumer market for external AI, not as a generator of our own capabilities.

70% of Dominican MSMEs acknowledge that AI will revolutionize the productive sector, but only 14% invest in it. Only 5% of companies have the capacity to hire staff and carry out AI projects effectively.

Meanwhile, we consume US$300 million a year in imported solutions that create no specialized local jobs, build no transferable know-how and generate no Dominican intellectual property.

When the government competes with the market

ECLAC highlights CiudadanIA as an emblematic case of AI application in the Dominican public sector. Technically competent, it uses machine learning and natural language processing models to collect citizen data and offer personalized assistance.

But its impact on the ecosystem deserves critical analysis from a game theory perspective. When the public sector positions itself as the main innovator, with virtually unlimited budgets and no pressure to deliver a return on investment, it creates a non-cooperative Nash equilibrium in which private actors rationally choose not to compete.

Why would an MSME invest scarce resources in developing AI solutions for smart government when the State is already developing CiudadanIA with a financial capacity that no private actor can match? They wouldn't. The business sector withdraws strategically, expecting the government to solve innovation problems while it concentrates on activities with lower regulatory risk.

Result: isolated government projects that do not scale to the productive ecosystem, do not generate sustainable specialized employment outside the public sector, and do not build capacity to export technological solutions.

The uncomfortable question: If CiudadanIA is our emblematic case, why don't we see dozens of Dominican startups competing for government AI contracts? Why is there no vibrant ecosystem of local technology providers? The answer: an institutional design that favors direct government execution over market building.

Infrastructure challenges

Infrastructure: The lack of robust data centers and nationwide cloud computing platforms limits the development of complex AI projects. Dependence on international cloud solutions perpetuates operating costs that are unsustainable in the long run.

Talent: Specialized training remains limited. Emerging talent migrates to international markets with better compensation. This drain of human capital restricts the capacity to carry out large-scale internal projects.

Digital divide: Despite internet penetration of 85%, 40% of the population lacks basic digital skills. This exclusion creates a social fracture in which the benefits of AI will amplify existing inequalities.

Regulatory framework: The absence of specific legislation to combat malicious uses such as (deepfakes), and the lack of rules on data privacy and the ethical use of algorithms, create a legal vacuum that inhibits responsible investment.

Coordination: Collaboration among universities, the private sector and government remains fragmented. This lack of coordination limits our capacity to advance applied research and develop patents.

Projecting the future cost

If we stay on the current trajectory, the gap with regional leaders will become impossible to close. Chile, Brazil and Uruguay will consolidate their position as technology innovation hubs. Mexico and Argentina will capture foreign direct investment that could have come to the Dominican Republic had we executed strategically. Here is a sample:

2030: Position 105+ in the GII (with the deterioration continuing at 1.4 positions per year) 2030: Position 12-15 in ILIA (overtaken by Ecuador, Panama, potentially El Salvador) 2025-2030: US$1.5 billion accumulated in imported AI consumption without generating local capabilities 2025-2030: 500-1000 specialized professionals emigrated without replacement 2030: Zero unicorns, zero universities in global rankings, zero Dominican tech brands recognized internationally

If we captured just 5% of the regional technology services market that Mexico and Argentina are building, we would generate US$200-300 million a year in tech exports, 5,000-10,000 direct specialized jobs, and multiplier effects across the education and business ecosystem.

Opportunities we will lose

The Dominican Republic has natural competitive advantages in sectors where AI could catalyze transformations—but only if we urgently build capabilities:

Tourism: 31 million Chinese travelers a year heading to North America. AI can capture a significant segment through advanced personalization. But without local technology companies, Dominican hotels will buy Spanish or American solutions.

Logistics: Back-office automation, predictive operations and smart assets can transform competitiveness. But without local developers, the free-trade zone will hire Mexican consultants.

Financial services: Advanced data analysis for credit scoring, fraud detection and financial inclusion. But without specialized talent, Dominican banks will license Brazilian software.

Climate adaptation: As a nation vulnerable to extreme events, AI can optimize water management, post-disaster energy distribution and early warning systems. But without researchers, ONAMET will buy Chilean predictive models.

Each of these «opportunities» will be captured by foreign companies with imported solutions if we do not act now.

Strategic recommendations

To reverse the decline and stop the transfer of value to external ecosystems:

Aggressive investment in endogenous capabilities:

 Set a target: 10% of AI spending (US$30M out of US$300M in 2025) directed to local development and research. Tax incentives for companies that not only adopt AI but invest in local innovation. 

Mass talent retention:

 Internationally competitive compensation (US$80K-120K for senior ML engineers), applied research opportunities, centers of excellence with competitive funding. If we can pay foreign consultants, we can pay local talent. 

Regulatory sandbox for AI:

 Replicate the success of the financial sandbox. Clear entry criteria, an approval process of 30 days at most, risk-proportionate supervision, 12-24 months to validate business models. Mandatory coordination among the Superintendencia de Bancos, INDOTEL and Industria y Comercio. 

Turn CiudadanIA into a market catalyst:

 Break it into modular components and tender the development to Dominican technology companies. The government defines requirements; the private sector executes and acquires capabilities. Every government tech contract above >US$500K must include a transfer clause: training of Dominican personnel, accessible source code, documentation in Spanish. 

National data and computing infrastructure:

 Robust data centers and cloud computing platforms that guarantee digital sovereignty. National data lakes in strategic sectors (health, education, climate) to enable applied research with local data. 

Dual university-industry programs:

 Every student in the last two years working 20 hours a week at companies in the AI consortium. Companies pay a competitive salary; universities validate the learning. Industry certifications required before graduation. 

Observatory with an accountability function:

 A Public/Private AI Observatory documenting success stories, monitoring trends and evaluating impact. A public dashboard updated quarterly with metrics: patents filed, scientific publications, companies in the sandbox, private investment in R&D, talent retained vs. emigrated. 

The decision we cannot postpone

As usual, next year we will publish our analysis comparing these GII and ILIA metrics against actual results, identifying progress or setbacks. After seven years of documenting systematic deterioration (2018-2025 in the GII, 2024-2025 in the ILIA), the question is no longer whether we have a problem but whether we have the will to solve it.

The price of complacency has been quantified: US$300 million a year transferred to external ecosystems, seven positions lost in the GII, three positions lost in the ILIA, position 138/139 in scientific output, zero unicorns, zero universities in global rankings, and specialized talent emigrating systematically.

We can stay on this trajectory—consuming without producing, investing without generating outputs, celebrating strategies without demanding execution—and in 2030 we will be at position 105+ in the GII, having spent a cumulative US$1.5 billion on imported solutions, watching Chile, Brazil, Uruguay, Mexico, Peru and Argentina consolidate innovative ecosystems that we could have built ourselves.

Or we can decide that the price already paid is enough. That five years of documented decline justify a radical change in priorities, resource allocation, institutional coordination and the demand for measurable results.

AI is already transforming the Dominican Republic—with the US$300 million we spend each year. The only open question is whether we will be architects or consumers of that transformation. Whether we will capture value or keep transferring it. Whether we will build capabilities or perpetuate dependence.

The decisions we make in the next 18-24 months will determine which of these futures we bring about. The cost of choosing badly is no longer theoretical. We have been paying it for five years. And every additional day of inaction makes it higher.