Efficiency without humanity
For more than two decades I have documented the evolution of e-commerce in the country. I can say that Dominican e-commerce was born late, pushed by pandemic urgency more than by strategic vision. But what should have been a leap toward modernity ended up being, in many cases, a digitalization of draconian practices that…

For more than two decades I have documented the evolution of e-commerce in the country. I can say that Dominican e-commerce was born late, pushed by pandemic urgency more than by strategic vision.
But what should have been a leap toward modernity ended up being, in many cases, a digitization of draconian practices that traditional retail never questioned. The result: systems that optimize delivery times while fully externalizing the cost of error onto those who can least afford to absorb it.
The success figures
Despite this reality, the e-commerce market in the Dominican Republic has grown substantially in recent years, with revenues reaching approximately 1,320 million US dollars in 2024. This represents an increase of 606,84 million dollars since 2017.
Tabuga Intelligence projections indicate that the market will continue to expand, with revenues expected to rise to 1,500 million dollars by 2026 and reach 1,800 million dollars by 2030, reflecting a compound annual growth rate (CAGR 2026-2030) of around 5 percent.
User penetration is expected to grow from 42.0 percent in 2026 to 45.0 percent in 2030, and the number of users will exceed 5.2 million by 2030.
A local case
Last week, a routine order through the Supermercado Nacional app ended in a mix-up of orders. A common logistical error, almost unavoidable in high-volume operations. What was extraordinary was not the error but what came after: the delivery worker calling on his own, visibly rushed and under pressure, trying to resolve a situation that far exceeded his capacity to act.
The reason was simple and brutal: the cost of the error —a purchase that could exceed his entire monthly salary— would fall directly on him. The problem worsened when the person who took the call was my son. The pressure passed on by the delivery worker turned into a disturbance that took the whole day to settle.
That cost —the real human cost of an operating model designed with no consideration for people— appears on no efficiency dashboard. There is no key business indicator that captures it. But someone pays it.
The architecture of transferred risk
What happened in my home is more than an anomaly. It is the predictable result of a systemic design in which the last-mile worker carries responsibilities that do not correspond to his role, his pay or his authority. It is the same logic I have criticized in the mobility sector: fragmented systems where risks are individualized while benefits are concentrated.
In the current Dominican eCommerce model, the delivery worker is simultaneously the face of the brand, the quality inspector, the contingency manager and the party financially responsible for any error in the chain. All this while working under time pressure, without decision-making tools and with the permanent threat of salary deductions that can exceed what he earns in a month.
Operations managers, trained in the school of measurable efficiency, design processes that work perfectly on paper: picking times optimized, routes calculated by algorithm, ever-narrower delivery windows. But that obsession with operational efficiency has created a vacuum where a system of co-responsibility should exist.
The consumer missing from the equation
There is a question Dominican digital retail does not answer: why can't the consumer decide to protect their order?
In the vehicle insurance sector, last year we talked about «financial protection that is activated before the loss event». It is a mechanism that prevents, that stabilizes, that distributes risk among those who can absorb it.
In local e-commerce, that mechanism simply does not exist. The consumer pays for the product, pays for the delivery, but has no option to pay for coverage that protects them —and protects the worker— against unavoidable contingencies.
The premise is not to look like a transfer of responsibility to the consumer, but to include them as a decision-making agent in an ecosystem of co-responsibility. If the operation's risks are shared, the solutions should be too. A low-cost order insurance —optionally activated by the consumer— could absorb logistical errors, damage in transit and losses, without the burden falling on the person least able to carry it.
The invisible cost of systemic pressure
When a brand designs its operation so that the delivery person calls the customer directly to solve problems that exceed their capacity, it is creating friction at the most vulnerable point of the chain. That anxious call does not only affect the worker and the immediate consumer. It affects entire families who must absorb a pressure that should never have reached their homes.
In my case, it was the emotional burden of calming my son. For the family that received our order by mistake, it was probably one more story of frustration. For the delivery person, it was a day of anxiety, calculating how much would be deducted from their pay. And the brand, meanwhile, only found out because I decided to escalate the complaint until I found an eCommerce manager willing to listen.
This is the paradox of efficiency without humanity: systems that work perfectly until they fail, and when they fail, the cost is paid by those with the least voice to complain.
Toward a model of digital co-responsibility
Our intention is not to demonize retail or to romanticize delivery work. It is to recognize that Dominican e-commerce needs to mature toward a model that, in our view, should include:
1) Operational risk has systemic coverage. Just as we require mandatory insurance to drive on the streets, there should be a protection mechanism for last-mile operations. Not as an additional cost for the vulnerable consumer, but as an integral part of the business model.
2) Consumers can choose their level of protection. Offering the option to insure an order —especially high-value ones— democratizes risk management and removes the pressure on the worker.
3) Errors are handled institutionally. When something fails, a protocol must be activated that does not depend on the delivery person's individual initiative or on the consumer's ability to escalate complaints.
4) Efficiency includes human metrics. Delivery time and cost per order cannot be the only indicators. The impact on workers and consumers must be part of how we evaluate service quality.
The next horizon of consumer protection
The Ley 358-05 on consumer protection in the Dominican Republic was designed for a world of in-person transactions. We call on public policy designers as well as on Proconsumidor's entities, because e-commerce operates in a territory that this law barely reaches, and where business practices have advanced faster than any regulatory framework.
Citizens cannot wait for the State to fully understand this transformation before acting. The experience of the insurance sector shows that when there is willingness to co-build, innovation can precede regulation without generating the chaos we saw with transportation platforms. What is needed is for the Dominican digital retail sector to recognize that its current model has unsustainable hidden costs —for workers, for consumers, and eventually for its own reputation.
Efficiency that sacrifices humanity is not efficiency; it becomes an externalization of costs onto those who cannot defend themselves. And in a country where e-commerce is only beginning to go mainstream, we have the chance to build something better before bad practices harden into an immovable norm.
Because in the end, behind every order there are people. Families waiting for their purchases, workers trying to earn a living with dignity, and a system that should protect all of its parties.