Digital risk toward the weakest link

The platform economy promised to democratize access to work and consumption. We have spent more than two decades analyzing local e-commerce patterns, and in practice we have seen architectures built in which risk flows systematically downward, concentrating on those with the least capacity to absorb it. Dominican e-commerce,…

The platform economy promised to democratize access to work and consumption. We have spent more than two decades analyzing local e-commerce patterns, and in practice we have seen architectures built in which risk flows systematically downward, concentrating on those with the least capacity to absorb it.

Dominican e-commerce, born under pandemic pressure, reproduces this pattern with a clarity that deserves critical examination. Behind every successful delivery there is a chain of algorithmic decisions, operating protocols and efficiency metrics.

Behind every error there is a person —usually a delivery worker— who bears consequences out of proportion to their role and income. This asymmetry is the result of business models that optimize costs by outsourcing risk to the most vulnerable link.

The success figures

Despite this reality, the e-commerce market in the Dominican Republic has grown substantially in recent years, with revenue reaching approximately 1,320 million US dollars in 2024. This represents an increase of 606,84 million dollars since 2017.

Projections from Tabuga Intelligence indicate that the market will keep expanding, with revenue expected to rise to 1,500 million dollars by 2026 and reach 1,800 million dollars by 2030, reflecting an annual growth rate (CAGR 2026-2030) of around 5 percent.

User penetration is expected to grow from 42.0 percent in 2026 to 45.0 percent in 2030, and the number of users will reach more than 5.2 million by 2030.

The hidden logic of transfer

A recent case involving an order placed with Supermercado Nacional illustrates this dynamic with uncomfortable precision. The order was swapped by mistake —a statistically inevitable situation in high-volume operations— and set off a revealing sequence: the delivery worker, facing deductions that could exceed his monthly salary, contacted my home directly to try to resolve on his own what an institutional system should be handling.

The call, charged with urgency and anxiety, was answered by my son. What followed was a full day of family disruption. An intangible human cost that no operating metric records but that someone inevitably absorbs.

This is not an isolated case. It is the visible manifestation of a systemic design in which the last-mile worker simultaneously takes on incompatible roles: brand representative, quality checker, contingency manager and financial guarantor of the entire chain. All of this with minimal pay, no decision-making authority and under a permanent threat of financial penalty.

The co-responsibility vacuum

In the article titled «Movilidad responsable y asegurada» I analyzed how the absence of financial protection mechanisms produces fragmented systems where «risks are shared but solutions are not». Dominican e-commerce replicates exactly this pattern.

The fundamental difference with the mobility sector is that there, at least, a regulatory framework exists —however insufficient— that provides for mandatory insurance. In e-commerce, consumers lack even the option of protecting their order. They cannot choose coverage against logistics errors, damage or loss. The risk is simply passed down until it finds whoever can least withstand it.

This absence of options reveals a view of the consumer as a passive recipient, not as a decision-making agent in an ecosystem of co-responsibility. It also reveals a view of the worker as an adjustment variable, not as a person whose economic and emotional stability deserves systemic protection.

Efficiency as an alibi

The operations departments of Dominican digital retail have adopted the language of optimization with notable enthusiasm. Picking times, algorithmic routes, ever-narrower delivery windows. Key business indicators (KPIs) that show continuous improvement in quantifiable metrics.

But efficiency measured exclusively in time and cost per transaction hides costs the system prefers not to see. The stress of a worker pressed to solve the unsolvable. The friction passed on to households that must absorb other people's emergencies. The gradual erosion of trust when consumers discover that, whatever the problem, they are on their own.

As I noted regarding the insurance sector, «digitalization has been efficient thanks to well-defined processes and its capacity to adapt to new models. The problem lies in the lack of shared governance, where technology is not only implemented but integrated under principles of traceability, equity and social responsibility.»

Dominican digital retail has implemented technology while, on some occasions, forgetting to integrate these principles. The result is operational efficiency built on human fragility.

Toward a new digital contract

The solution, rather than rejecting digitalization, does not seek to romanticize earlier models either. It involves recognizing that every technological architecture embodies ethical decisions, and that those decisions can —and must— be revised. Here are my considerations:

A model of digital co-responsibility requires concrete transformations. First, coverage mechanisms that absorb operational risk without passing it on to the individual worker. Just as mandatory vehicle insurance stabilizes the mobility system, an equivalent should exist for last-mile operations.

Second, including the consumer as a decision-making agent. Offering the option to insure orders —especially high-value ones— democratizes risk management and creates a fund that protects everyone in the chain.

Third, institutional protocols for managing contingencies. When something fails, a system must kick in that does not depend on the worker's desperate initiative or on the consumer's ability to escalate complaints until they find someone willing to listen.

Fourth, metrics that include human dimensions. The impact on workers and consumers must be part of how we evaluate service quality, not just delivery speed.

The moment of decision

If we consider that the Ley 358-05 on consumer protection was designed for in-person transactions, then we can infer that local e-commerce operates in a territory this framework barely reaches.

And as happened with digital transport platforms, innovation has preceded regulation, leaving gaps that business practices fill according to their own logic.

In the article Movilidad responsable y asegurada» I argued that «without coordination among those who design the laws, those who enforce them, those who insure and those who educate, mobility will remain a set of isolated efforts that barely manage to contain the disorder».

The same applies to e-commerce: without a common framework that integrates worker protection, consumer rights and aligned business incentives, we will keep seeing systems that work perfectly until they fail —and when they fail, the cost is paid by those with the least voice.

Dominican e-commerce is at an early stage of mass adoption. It is still possible to build something better before bad practices harden into an immovable norm. But that requires acknowledging that technology is not neutral: it embodies values, distributes power and assigns risks.

Beyond asking whether or not we digitalize, the real focus is to analyze how to do it in a way that protects every participant in the ecosystem.

Because behind every algorithm there are human decisions. And behind every order there are people who deserve a system designed to protect them, not to pass on to them the costs that others prefer not to bear.

—

This article is part of a broader reflection on co-responsibility in the digital economy, in continuity with our article published in this same newspaper, titled “Movilidad responsable y asegurada«.