Citizen or foreign traveler?
An email from the Ministry of Tourism thanking a Dominican citizen for their «stay» shows how the eTicket reuses immigration data without notice or consent. A reflection on design flaws, the Ley 172-13 and the State that does not recognize its own people.

The email arrived a few hours after we cleared Immigration. The Ministry of Tourism thanked us for our "stay" in the Dominican Republic. We had left our own country, on Dominican passports, headed to a work engagement. The system had nonetheless decided we were visitors. That small labeling error captures a larger problem: how the Dominican State looks at its citizens once it turns them into data.
The eTicket is the screen that comes before the counter. It folds into a single QR code what used to be three paper forms: the embarkation and disembarkation card, the customs declaration, and the sworn health declaration. It is free, mandatory, and more than eleven million people go through it every year, among them tourists, residents, and a diaspora that returns in December and in summer. Langdon Winner once wrote that artifacts have politics: a bridge, a dam, or a form embeds decisions about who commands and who obeys. The eTicket faithfully reproduces the State's org chart. One section for Immigration, another for Customs, another for Public Health. Each institution asks for its own fields, and the passenger receives the sum of three bureaucracies on a single screen. The flow belongs to the official; the phone, to the citizen.
The new version that Immigration released recently promised to ease that burden. In practice it shows the symptoms of a prototype. When you register your departure from the country, the system also offers to generate the entry ticket for your return. The option appears, can be selected, and confirms. The entry code is never generated. The traveler believes they are carrying both and discovers the failure only once they are back, in a foreign airport, with an unstable connection and a line behind them. A form that claims to exist when it has failed costs more trust than a form that is absent.
One technical detail explains a good part of the anxiety in the lines. When the phone loses signal for a few seconds, the new portal shows a notice about the "socket" connection, and the screen stays locked until it is restored. That behavior reveals the architecture chosen: an application that keeps the form's state on the server and syncs it with the browser through a permanent channel, so that every field typed and every button pressed depends on a live connection. It is a convenient pattern for the development team, because it concentrates the logic in one place, and a hostile one for whoever fills out the form in a taxi, at the boarding gate, or in a foreign airport with intermittent wifi. A service designed for the passenger would work the other way around: it would save progress on the device itself, tolerate disconnection without losing anything, and speak in human language when something fails.
"Socket" is an engineer's word; "we are saving your progress, you can continue when you get your signal back" is a public-service sentence. The difference between the two sums up who was at the table when the system was designed.
That flaw betrays an incomplete launch method. A service of this scale demands testing under real scenarios, load testing in high season, testing on mid-range phones over slow networks, and a gradual rollout with a limited pilot. Dominican banking operates this way because the regulator requires it. Airlines do too, because an error costs flights. Immigration has shown that it listens: the previous version added the creation of a ticket from a prior one, and users on the institutional forum were grateful for it. The current problem lies in the criterion that defines when a system is ready. When that criterion is missing, the whole country becomes a laboratory.
Back to the email. Its existence confirms that the exit migration data feeds a mass-mailing campaign by a ministry that the eTicket's own rules leave out. The portal warns that each passenger must complete the information truthfully "for the General Directorate of Immigration, the General Directorate of Customs, and the Ministry of Public Health, in accordance with laws 285-04, 115-17, 72-02 and 226-06". Three institutions, four laws, one clear mandate. The Ministry of Tourism appears in none of those lines.
Shoshana Zuboff, in her book, The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power (PublicAffairs, 2019), described how private platforms extract behavioral surplus from every interaction for purposes the user never authorized. When that logic is installed in the State, the effect is graver, because the citizen has no option to refuse: the eTicket is mandatory by law and the passport is held at the counter until the code appears. Article 44, numeral 2, of the Constitution recognizes every person's right to know what data about them is held in public and private records, what becomes of it and how it is used, and to demand its rectification or destruction when it affects their rights. Ley 172-13 on personal data protection sets out the principle of purpose: data is collected for a specific purpose, its use for different or incompatible purposes is prohibited, and any additional processing requires the data subject's informed consent or an express legal authorization. The four laws underpinning the eTicket authorize migration, customs, and health control. A tourism thank-you campaign lacks that authorization, and consent was never requested.
It is true that the platform is co-administered with the Ministry of Tourism through Viajero Digital, and that interinstitutional exchange may be grounded in the design. Even so, citizens have the right to know this in advance, through a visible privacy notice, and to decide whether they accept promotional communications. Without notice and without consent, the constitutional guarantee is left in suspension. And there is something subtler at stake. A State that thanks its own citizen for their stay reveals that its data system has no category for them. It has reduced them to tourist flow, to a statistical unit of arrival and departure. The political bond between the person and their republic dissolves into a marketing template.
That dissolution has historical roots. For decades, the Dominican's relationship with the airport was marked by permanent departure or temporary return. The State learned to count visitors because tourism paid the bills, and it developed less vocabulary for the citizen on the move. The eTicket inherits that asymmetry. Digital identity could correct it: the biometric passport has been in circulation since February of this year, and the cédula carries decades of digitization. A form designed around the citizen would prefill what the State already knows and ask only what has changed. Estonia and Singapore solved this with interoperable identity. The foundations exist here; what is missing is the decision to build on them.
The implications go beyond the procedure. Trust in the State's digital services works like an ecosystem: each visible failure reduces citizens' willingness to adopt the next service, and each misuse of data feeds suspicion about all the other records. A country that aspires to a knowledge-based economy needs its citizens to trust public digital infrastructure as naturally as they trust the water from the tap. The reality is that Dominicans still in 2026 cannot drink water from the tap.
The horizon is within reach. Publish the eTicket's privacy notice and separate the migration database from any communication campaign. Enable a channel for reporting failures inside the form, a contingency mode in airports, and public metrics on usage and errors. And, at the structural level, a permanent product team at Immigration that treats the service as a living organism corrected daily, rather than a project that is delivered and forgotten.
The Ministry of Tourism's email was, in its own way, a lesson. It reminded us that a State is also defined by the category it assigns to whoever crosses its border. When the system recognizes the Dominican as a citizen and data as a right, the eTicket will stop being a form and become what it should have been from the start: the door of a republic that knows who its people are.