A Symptom of Poor Coordination

Last Friday, 13 November, the Ministry of Public Administration released circular 004450-2026, dated 4 November. The document gives the initial instructions for applying the National Framework for Interoperability and Data Governance under Decree 403-26.

Last Friday, November 13, the Ministry of Public Administration released circular 004450-2026, dated November 4. The document gives the initial instructions for applying the National Framework for Interoperability and Data Governance under Decree 403-26. Each institution must appoint an Institutional Data Governance Officer and a Technical Interoperability Officer, and must also identify the main information exchanges it already maintains with other entities.

On November 11, when discussing Decree 787-26, we wrote: «As of this writing, no public portal brings those agreements together». The circular leads us to the same diagnosis by another route, by requesting the minimum conditions for the State to know which exchanges exist. We acknowledge the step.

The first cohort comprises 33 institutions. The circular gives them 120 days from the publication of Resolution 226-2026 to submit the preliminary version of their plan. With that information, the MAP will draw up the Initial National Data and Interoperability Map.

Paragraph 12 warns that “the existence of an agreement does not in itself constitute sufficient legal grounds to access, communicate or exchange data when such processing is not permitted by the legal order”. Paragraph 14 adds that the Framework leaves personal data protection regimes intact.

What remains pending

The form proposed by the MAP asks for five fields: the counterpart institution, the information exchanged, the general purpose, the mechanism, and the role of provider or consumer. The legal basis is left out. In our proposal to DIGEIG, that field was the centerpiece.

The map is born as an internal document: the circular speaks of institutional, sectoral and domain views, but not of publishing it. We ask that the Initial National Map be published on the datos.gob.do portal, under the coordination of the MAP and DIGEIG.

In March 2020 we addressed a similar case: «If [the authorities] obtain the data lawfully, they must answer questions about its origin when asked». Today that answer can be automated. Such is the case of Estonia, home of the X-Road platform. Since 2017 its data tracker has allowed every citizen to see which institution consulted their data. If we already use X-Road, the same kind of digital oversight can be set up. We propose a log of queries visible to the data subject, showing the institution, the date and the legal basis invoked.

The officers are appointed from among existing civil servants. The circular sets a submission deadline but omits targets and consequences. We propose that the MAP publish the list of officers, and also that the Initial Cut flag the exchanges with no identified legal basis and set a deadline to regularize or suspend them.

The circular does not mention Decree 787-26, and that decree does not refer to the interoperability framework either. Two inventories are under way. One surveys artificial intelligence systems within 180 days and the other surveys data exchanges within 120 days. We propose that both share a single form, so that each high-impact system declares through which exchange it receives its data.

«Users are safeguards of their data. As a user and as a citizen, you cannot delegate that function to a third party», we argued before the pandemic. We applaud the steps taken, but we must always remember that transparency options, data rights and citizens' means of redress cannot arrive as after-the-fact patches to any system. The gaps in the law, the decrees and the circular could be read as safeguards for mechanisms designed to weaken civil liberties. We hope it is simply a symptom of poor coordination.

Originally published in Listín Diario on November 19, 2026.